Cover of Noise: A Flaw in Human Judgment

Book Highlights

Noise: A Flaw in Human Judgment

by Daniel Kahneman

Screvi keeps your highlights from books, articles, newsletters and more in one place, so you stop forgetting what you read.

What it's about

Errors in judgment stem from two distinct sources: bias, which is a systematic deviation from the truth, and noise, which is unwanted, random variation. This book explains why organizations and individuals consistently underestimate the amount of noise in their decisions and provides practical strategies to improve accuracy by reducing that variability.

Key ideas

  • The noise-bias distinction: Error is not just about being consistently wrong, but also about the random, unpredictable scatter in decisions that should ideally be consistent.
  • The judgment instrument: Since the human mind acts as a measurement tool, it is prone to invisible fluctuations caused by mood, time of day, and personal temperament.
  • The value of independent perspectives: Seeking an outside opinion is significantly more effective at reducing error than simply asking yourself the same question twice.
  • The illusion of consensus: Organizations often prioritize harmony over dissent, which suppresses the healthy disagreement necessary to identify and correct noisy judgments.

You'll love this book if...

  • You are a leader or manager trying to standardize decision-making processes within a team or organization.
  • You want to understand why experts in fields like medicine or law often reach wildly different conclusions when reviewing the same information.
  • You are interested in behavioral economics and practical methods to remove randomness from your professional life.

Best for

Professionals in high-stakes fields like finance, medicine, or policy who need to create more reliable and consistent decision-making systems.

Books with the same vibe

  • Thinking, Fast and Slow by Daniel Kahneman
  • Predictably Irrational by Dan Ariely
  • Superforecasting by Philip E. Tetlock and Dan Gardner

30 popular highlights from this book

Key Insights & Memorable Quotes

The most popular highlights from Noise: A Flaw in Human Judgment, saved by readers on Screvi.

To understand error in judgment, we must understand both bias and noise.
Save
wherever there is judgment, there is noise—and more of it than you think.
Save
There is at least one source of occasion noise that we have all noticed: mood.
Save
Bias and noise—systematic deviation and random scatter—are different components of error.
Save
Causally, noise is nowhere; statistically, it is everywhere.
Save
Most organizations prefer consensus and harmony over dissent and conflict. The procedures in place often seem expressly designed to minimize the frequency of exposure to actual disagreements and, when such disagreements happen, to explain them away.
Save
Life is often more complex than the stories we like to tell about it.
Save
It is more useful to pay attention to people who disagree with you than to pay attention to those who agree.
Save

Keep the quotes that hit you. Save them to Screvi with this book's top highlights.

Save free
In a negotiation situation, for instance, good mood helps. People in a good mood are more cooperative and elicit reciprocation. They tend to end up with better results than do unhappy negotiators.
Save
people are rarely aware of their own biases when they are being misled by them. This lack of awareness is itself a known bias, the bias blind spot. People often recognize biases more easily in others than they do in themselves
Save
Averaging two guesses by the same person does not improve judgments as much as does seeking out an independent second opinion. As Vul and Pashler put it, “You can gain about 1/10th as much from asking yourself the same question twice as you can from getting a second opinion from someone else.” This is not a large improvement. But you can make the effect much larger by waiting to make a second guess.
Save
There is good reason to believe that general intelligence is likely to be associated with better judgment. Intelligence is correlated with good performance in virtually all domains. All other things being equal, it is associated not only with higher academic achievement but also with higher job performance.
Save
people who make judgments behave as if a true value exists, regardless of whether it does.
Save
it is hard to agree with reality if you cannot agree with yourself.
Save
On the other hand, a good mood makes us more likely to accept our first impressions as true without challenging them.
Save
When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do?”)
Save

Keep the quotes that hit you. Save them to Screvi with this book's top highlights.

Save free
Noise is mostly a by-product of our uniqueness, of our “judgment personality.
Save
In terms of noise, psychiatry is an extreme case.
Save
good judgments depend on what you know, how well you think, and how you think.
Save
Scientists in diverse disciplines were quick to adopt the least squares method. Over two centuries later, it remains the standard way to evaluate errors wherever achieving accuracy is the goal.
Save
When physicians are under time pressure, they are apparently more inclined to choose a quick-fix solution, despite its serious downsides.
Save
When Vul and Pashler let three weeks pass before asking their subjects the same question again, the benefit rose to one-third the value of a second opinion.
Save
Judgment is not a synonym for thinking, and making accurate judgments is not a synonym for having good judgment.
Save
People cannot be faulted for failing to predict the unpredictable, but they can be blamed for a lack of predictive humility.
Save

Keep the quotes that hit you. Save them to Screvi with this book's top highlights.

Save free
Judgment can therefore be described as measurement in which the instrument is a human mind.
Save
if we want people to feel that they have been treated with respect and dignity, we might have to tolerate some noise.
Save
Whatever their flaws, rankings are less noisy than ratings.
Save
There is essentially no evidence of situations in which people do very poorly and models do very well with the same information.
Save
chance variation in a small number of early movers” can have major effects in tipping large populations
Save
objective ignorance accumulates steadily the further you look into the future.
Save

Find Another Book

Search by title or author to explore highlights from other books.

Try it with your highlights

Create your account, add your highlights and see how Screvi can change the way you read.

Try It With Your Highlights14-day free trial. No credit card required.